Reviewer packet / human review pending

External Reviewer Packet

Use this route as an inspection order, not as a claim summary. It starts with what is not claimed, then routes you to current state, burden evidence, ontology documents, and source authority.

Read boundaries Specialist starts

Diagram showing the reviewer packet moving from claim boundaries to current state, Distance-to-GR, ontology documents, source inspection, reviewer questions, human review pending, and no-completed-derivation boundary. — Reviewer inspection starts with claim boundaries before source inspection.Mermaid source: docs/content-dossiers/reviewer-packet/diagrams/reviewer-inspection-order.mmd. Manifest id: comprehension_reviewer_inspection_order.

Packet status

This is a human-review-pending inspection route.

The packet exists because prerequisite authority and orientation pages now exist. It does not report review completion or scientific approval.

Review status: Human review pendingThis packet is staged for reviewer use. It is not peer review, external validation, or approval.
Snapshot date: 2026-06-29Checked-in website source-state snapshot at commit c7369577a7e5....
Active task: RT-20260614-288Latest handoff: handoff-0321. Read the current-state route for source details.
Packet scope: Inspection orderThe page routes reviewers to source-bound pages before source/provenance inspection.

Claim boundaries first

Review the narrow claim, not an inflated one.

The current-state snapshot is useful only when read with its forbidden implications. The boundary below appears before source inspection so the review target cannot silently expand.

What is claimed for review: Scoped source-extension evidence/preconditionThe checked-in current-state snapshot reports scoped recovery-bridge-candidate evidence/precondition acceptance under finite/local source-side scope.
What that does not claim: No adoption or completed derivationNo source-law adoption, no MetricData(E) adoption, no g_eff scope change, no coupling-law adoption, no matter-coupling derivation or adoption, no stress-energy semantics, no Einstein equations, no benchmark promotion, and no completed derivation occurred.
What the website can do: Orient and linkThe website can organize current state, route burdens, documents, diagrams, and source links. It cannot become scientific authority.
Review status: PendingThis route is a human-review-pending inspection packet. It does not report external review completion.

Inspection order

Read these internal routes before opening source files.

Internal pages explain the reader job and boundaries. Source links and manifests remain available as provenance once the review question is precise.

Source authority

Start with the rule that upstream source files, registries, and governed records own claim status.

Open route

Claim Boundary Explorer

Inspect allowed, forbidden, and gate-required wording before reading any stronger summary.

Open route

Current physics state

Read the active task, latest handoff, blocked claims, and next source-side action.

Open route

Distance-to-GR dashboard

Review derivation burdens and blockers without treating them as a progress score.

Open route

Ontology documents

Use the reading guide for registered TeX sources and generated PDF derivatives.

Open route

Specialist guided starts

Choose the physicist, mathematician, AI/agent, or system-engineering path matching your review question.

Open route

Deeper inspection

Use these routes for claim-specific review.

These pages help separate benchmark status, derivation roadmap, source extension, frozen routes, validation limits, and publication evidence.

Exact-GR benchmark boundary

Separate exact-GR benchmark compatibility from first-principles derivation and benchmark promotion.

Open route

GR derivation roadmap

Inspect source, metric, matter-coupling, equation, and promotion burdens as separate obligations.

Open route

Source extension pipeline

Read proposal-only and draft/control work without treating it as adopted source law.

Open route

Negative results and frozen routes

Distinguish scoped obstruction and frozen local routes from global theory rejection.

Open route

Validator PASS limits

Check why command PASS is bounded checked-state evidence, not theorem proof.

Open route

Publication and provenance system

Inspect route maps, page provenance, source manifests, asset manifests, and hash limits.

Open route

Reviewer questions

Make the review target explicit before judging it.

Question

Which claim is under review?

Name the exact page and boundary before evaluating evidence. Avoid reviewing a stronger claim than the source permits.

Question

Which source owns the claim?

Find the registry, handoff, TeX source, or source-analysis artifact before relying on a website summary.

Question

Which gate is still closed?

Identify whether the issue is source-law adoption, MetricData(E), g_eff, matter coupling, Einstein equations, or benchmark promotion.

Question

What would change the status?

Look for the next bounded packet, acceptance criteria, obstruction, freeze, or human gate named by the source-state page.

Safe reading

The packet is safe only if the unsafe shortcut remains visible.

Safe summary: Source-first inspection orderThe reviewer packet gives an external reviewer a source-first inspection order and visible claim boundaries.
Unsafe summary: Review packet equals validationThe reviewer packet proves scientific viability, external validation, completed GR derivation, MetricData(E), g_eff, matter coupling, Einstein equations, benchmark promotion, or downstream GR promotion.